The K-pop industry experienced another shock when the news about BTS’s Jungkook and aespa’s Winter dating rumors suddenly appeared all over social media. At first, it was just a wave of fans guessing, but then it turned into a huge and very negative reaction with the main target being Winter. This whole thing got so bad that SM Entertainment had to get involved and made it clear that they are already taking legal actions.
Over the past weeks, multiple online communities have seen a surge of harmful posts related to Winter—ranging from fabricated “evidence,” manipulated images, invasive speculation, and even sexually explicit comments. The escalation occurred shortly after claims surfaced online that Jungkook and Winter allegedly had matching tattoos and matching nail designs. Although no company confirmed the dating speculation, the rumor alone triggered a massive wave of online attacks—almost entirely directed at Winter.
On December 10, SM Entertainment officially addressed the situation through their reporting system “KWANGYA 119,” where fans frequently submit reports regarding defamation, harassment, and harmful online behavior. The agency confirmed that they are not only collecting evidence but also actively pursuing criminal complaints and civil lawsuits.
Malicious Comments Skyrocket After Dating Rumors
Dating rumors are not new in the K-pop industry, but the reaction to the Jungkook–Winter speculation grew unusually toxic. Within hours of the rumor spreading, fans noticed a flood of degrading posts targeting Winter on platforms such as:
- DC Inside
- Women’s Generation
- Nate Pann
- Instiz
- TheQoo
- Instagram
- X (formerly Twitter)
- YouTube
- Multiple anonymous Korean forums
Many posts went beyond simple gossip. SM revealed that comments included personal attacks, sexual harassment, character defamation, invasion of privacy, and even deepfake content. Some users allegedly spread edited images of Winter paired with Jungkook to make the rumors appear real. Others posted vulgar remarks and mocked both idols for the speculation.
While Jungkook was mentioned in the rumors, the majority of malicious content targeted Winter—a pattern that has occurred in several previous female idol dating rumors as well.
SM Entertainment Confirms Legal Action: ‘No Leniency’
In their official statement, SM Entertainment clearly stated that they are fully aware of the seriousness of the situation. The agency confirmed:
Criminal complaints have already been filed
Cases include defamation, sexual harassment, insult, false information spread, creation of manipulated content, and deepfakes.
Civil lawsuits are also being pursued
This means offenders may face financial penalties in addition to possible criminal sentences.
Investigations are ongoing
SM shared that some offenders from earlier monitoring have already received guilty verdicts, including prison sentences (up to 3 years) and fines.
Evidence is being collected extensively
SM noted that they have secured large amounts of screenshots, videos, and logs documenting malicious behavior.
More legal action will come in waves
The company plans to “expand legal action step by step” after reviewing additional posts.
Most importantly, SM emphasized that they will respond strictly without leniency, meaning no warnings or forgiveness will be given once a harmful post is identified.
Why the Rumor Escalated So Much
The dating rumor arose from the observations made by online users pointing out:
- Hand tattoos of both artists that look the same
- The nails of both artists being of the same design
- The coincidence of the Instagram posts in terms of the time they were made
Even though these similarities were never officially connected, the rumor was able to gain rapid momentum powered by:
- The huge fanbases of both BTS and aespa
- Previous speculation surrounding Jungkook’s private life
- A current trend that sees female idols getting sexist backlash for dating rumors
Neither HYBE (the agency representing BTS) nor SM Entertainment has made any comment on the dating rumor issue so far. However, their lack of communication did not help the matter; rather, it fuelled the online debate even more.
Winter, the one associated with the rumors, became a victim of blame, insults, defamation, and harassment despite the fact that there was no proof of any kind to support the claim of her being in a relationship with Jungkook
Why SM Entertainment’s Response Matters
This situation highlights a larger problem in the K-pop industry:
Female idols, particularly younger ones, often face cruel public judgment, especially in dating-related controversies. Even unfounded gossip can rapidly escalate into a flood of hate.
The tough legal position that SM Entertainment has taken communicates a vital message:
- The privacy of idols must be honored
- If there is any dating at all, it is not a crime.
- No false accusations or harassment is going to be tolerated
- Creating deepfake content and posting edited images are both illegal
The anonymity of the internet will no longer serve as a shield for the wrongdoers
In the past couple of years, the Korean entertainment industry has resorted more and more to legal actions as a result of the rising cases of cyberbullying. The strong stand taken by SM is an indication of the increasing concern about the mental health and safety of idols.
Public Reaction: Split but Mainly Supportive
The overall response on social media has been varied:
Fan community is on SM’s side
Fan, that is, one who idolizes Winter, admits that the company’s policy is good, but at the same time is trying to seek protection for her.
Others think that SM should also come out with a statement regarding the dating rumor
Yet, the norm is that companies seldom confirm unless both sides agree.
A minority still pushes the rumor
Despite the legal warning, some continue to make edited content or speculative posts.
However, a large portion of the public agrees that malicious comments have gone too far and should be penalized.
Winter’s Silence: A Professional Response
Throughout the situation, Winter has remained completely silent. She has not reacted on social media nor addressed the rumors, showing professionalism despite the intense hate.
SM’s message makes it clear that she shouldn’t have to endure such treatment just because of unverified online speculation.
What Happens Next?
From what SM claimed we might anticipate the following:
1. Numerous legal complains
SM will gradually file suits as the evidence gets processed more and more.
2. Tough punishments for the violators
The Korean law is now applying severe punishments for online harassment.
3. Continuous supervision of net communities
Less nasty comments as the fear of getting sued increases
Winter may receive some calm amid the agency’s fierce elimination of the harassment perpetrators.
Join Our WhatsApp Channel
Conclusion
The Winter case of aespa is a perfect example of the K-pop fandom culture’s dark side. Harassment after rumors was, however, extreme, unacceptable, and very damaging. Taking strong legal actions—criminal and civil—by SM Entertainment represents a clear movement to protect idols from continuous online abuse.
Irrespective of the truth behind the Jungkook–Winter rumors, no idol should be attacked, sexualized, or defamed upon mere conjecture. The K-pop community is maturing, and this incident may very well become a precedent for agencies to adopt more progressive approaches in dealing with online harassment, thus guaranteeing artists’ safety, dignity, and mental health.
Winter’s career is still her main focus, and SM has assured to support her “without any mercy” throughout the whole process. The fans’ wish is that this is a start of a digital environment that is safer for all the K-pop idols.
